• Login
    • Join
  • Subscribe Free
    • Magazine
    • eNewsletter
    Checkout
    • Magazine
    • News
    • Components
    • Markets
    • Materials
    • Solutions
    • Top 20 Companies
    • Buyers Guide
    • Events
    • More
  • Magazine
  • News
  • Components
  • Markets
  • Materials
  • Solutions
  • Top 20 Companies
  • Buyers Guide
  • Events
  • Current & Past Issues
    Features
    Editorial
    Departments
    Columns
    Digital Edition
    eNewsletter Archive
    Editorial Guidelines
    Staff
    Subscribe Now
    Advertise Now
    Top Features
    Digital Printing Delivers in Many Ways

    Precision Dispensing

    Color Cosmetics: Packaging Self-Expression

    What’s New in Nail Trends?

    Stock Packaging for Customization and Exclusivity
    Breaking News
    Regulatory
    Events
    Association
    Packaging
    Adv/Marketing
    Financial
    Retail & Travel
    People
    Products
    Experts
    Press Releases
    Exclusives
    Live From Shows
    Top News
    Coty Debuts First-of-its-Kind Beauty 'Magic Mirror' at Bourjois Boutique

    Maybelline New York Has A New Global Spokesmodel

    REN Skincare's Recyclable Bottle Contains Reclaimed Ocean Plastic

    This New Cannabis-Inspired Fragrance is Celebrating 4-20 Today

    MAC Partners with Puma -- So Sneakers Now Match Lipstick
    3D
    Accessories
    Aerosols
    Airless
    Applicators
    Bags
    Bottles/Jars
    Brushes
    Cans
    Cartons/Boxes
    Closures
    Compacts
    Devices
    Dispensers
    Double Duty
    Droppers
    Environmental
    Labels
    Lipstick packages
    Mascara Containers
    Paper
    Pouches
    Printing
    Pumps
    Rollerballs
    Small Sizes
    Stock Pkg
    Tubes
    Wipes/Sheets

    Maybelline New York Has A New Global Spokesmodel

    REN Skincare's Recyclable Bottle Contains Reclaimed Ocean Plastic

    Who Will Win The Fragrance Foundation’s Packaging of the Year Award?

    Tapematic USA to Install Two More PST Lines

    Burt's Bees Launches National Recycling Program
    Bath/Body
    Cosmetics
    Ethnic
    Fragrances
    Hair
    Health and Beauty
    Home Fragrance
    Men
    Nails
    Personal Care
    Sample/Travel Sizes
    Sets/Kits
    Skin

    Coty Debuts First-of-its-Kind Beauty 'Magic Mirror' at Bourjois Boutique

    Maybelline New York Has A New Global Spokesmodel

    This New Cannabis-Inspired Fragrance is Celebrating 4-20 Today

    Who Will Win The Fragrance Foundation’s Packaging of the Year Award?

    MAC Partners with Puma -- So Sneakers Now Match Lipstick
    Brush Fibers
    Eco-friendly
    Flexibles
    Glass
    Metal
    Paper/Board
    PCR
    PET
    Plastics
    Wood

    REN Skincare's Recyclable Bottle Contains Reclaimed Ocean Plastic

    Who Will Win The Fragrance Foundation’s Packaging of the Year Award?

    Tapematic USA to Install Two More PST Lines

    Burt's Bees Launches National Recycling Program

    Sephora's Seashell-Shaped Sponges Look Like Something Else, The Internet Says
    Anti-Counterfeit
    Contract Services
    Decorative Effects
    Design Capabilities
    Digital Printing
    Injection Molding
    Machinery
    Made in USA
    Package Development
    Printing/Decorating
    Sustainable Pkg/Practices
    Turnkey

    Who Will Win The Fragrance Foundation’s Packaging of the Year Award?

    Sephora's Seashell-Shaped Sponges Look Like Something Else, The Internet Says

    How Winning Brands Differentiate with Digital Packaging

    What Are Your Colors Saying?

    Beauty and the Environment
    Top 20 Companies
    AmorePacific

    Mary Kay

    Henkel

    Kao

    Estée Lauder
    All Companies
    Categories
    Company Profiles
    Add New Company
    International Buyers Guide Companies
    Auber Packaging Co., Ltd

    ZHEJIANG B.I. INDUSTRIAL CO., LTD.

    Federal Package

    East Hill Industries, Inc.

    JFA-Flock Applikationen GmbH
    Industry Events
    Live From Show
    Exhibitor Showcase
    Webinars

    Who Will Win The Fragrance Foundation’s Packaging of the Year Award?

    Announcing the Finalists in the 2018 CEW Beauty Awards

    The Perfumed Plume Reveals the Finalists

    A Closer Look at the 2018 Cosmopack Award Winners

    Cosmoprof & Cosmopack Celebrate Award Winners
    • Magazines
      • Current / Back Issues
      • Features
      • Editorial
      • Departments
      • Columns
      • Digital Edition
      • eNewsletter Archive
      • Staff
      • Editorial Guidelines
      • Subscribe Now
      • Advertise Now
    • Breaking News
    • Buyers Guide
      • Companies
      • Categories
      • Corporate Capabilities
      • Add Your Company
    • Components
      • 3D
      • Accessories
      • Aerosols
      • Airless
      • Applicatiors
      • Bags
      • Bottles / Jars
      • Brushes
      • Cans
      • Cartoons / Boxes
      • Closures
      • Compacts
      • Devices
      • Dispensers
      • Double Duty
      • Droppers
      • Environmental
      • Labels
      • Lipstick Packages
      • Mascara Containers
      • Paper
      • Pouches
      • Printing
      • Pumps
      • Rollerballs
      • Small Sizes
      • Stock Pkg
      • Tubes
      • Wipes/Sheets
    • Markets
      • Bath/Body
      • Cosmetics
      • Ethnic
      • Fragrances
      • Hair
      • Health And Beauty
      • Home Fragrance
      • Men
      • Nails
      • Personal Care
      • Simple/Travel Sizes
      • Sets/Kits
      • Skin
    • Materials
      • Brush Fibers
      • Eco-friendly
      • Flexibles
      • Glass
      • Metal
      • Paper/Board
      • PCR
      • PET
      • Plastics
      • Wood
    • Solutions
      • Anti-Counterfeit
      • Cotract Services
      • Decorative Effects
      • Design Capabilities
      • Digital Printing
      • Injection Molding
      • Machinery
      • Made In USA
      • Package Development
      • Printing/Decorating
      • Sustainable Pkg/Practices
      • Turnkey
    • Top 20 Companies
    • Online Exclusives
    • Slideshows
    • Expert Opinions
    • Videos
    • Infographics
    • Whitepapers
    • Products Showcase
    • Events
      • Industry Events
      • Live From Show Events
      • Webinars
    • Careers
    • About Us
      • About Us
      • Contact Us
      • Advertise With Us
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms Of Use
    Expert's Opinion

    4 Approaches to Creative Leadership in CPG Companies

    In the constantly evolving world of CPG brand design, knowledge is key.

    Related CONTENT
    • Perricone MD Names New Chief Supply Chain Officer
    • Lindal Group Appoints Global Operations Director
    • Arcade Beauty Invests in New Sampling Technology
    • Nuxe Adopts Oval Tense Tube from Cosmogen
    • Virospack Introduces Texturized End Decoration
    Scott Lucas and Jen Bethke07.17.17

    Developing and maintaining a clear approach to managing brand design within a CPG company can be a tough but decisively productive way to make brand design more efficient. How you’re doing it now may ultimately not deliver the best results.

    Something that appears to work for other brands may not be the best approach for your brand model. When the grass always appears greener on the other side of the fence, you must decide whether or not to jump over.

    Just to give some context, approaches to managing brand design have changed drastically over the last 10 years. Historically, Agency of Record (AOR) relationships were typical, with large external agencies responsible for the bulk of brand work. At the time, this made a lot of sense because channels of communication between consumers and brands were traditional—print, radio and TV.

    However, as the internet changed the way brands interact with consumers, communication touchpoints exploded. There were simply more ways to communicate as a brand—and it became important to find and work with agencies that excelled in these channels as well: In essence, driving down the prevalence of one AOR relationship and driving up the need for multiple-agency relationships, with design playing a much larger role internally through creative leadership and design management.

    Based on our experience with clients who represent many ways of managing brand design, we have provided four approaches from several large CPG companies to understand emerging approaches.

    A New Way to Look at Managing Design: Common Archetypes

    There are 12 common archetypes that describe basic human motivations. Each type has its own set of values, meaning and personality types. These markers for human motivations can also be used to illuminate the motivations of brands. Both for consumers and brands, archetypes build trust and authenticity by communicating core values consistently. To better define, evaluate and understand each design approach, we have aligned each to an archetype. This helps clients and agencies understand motivations, recognize fears, communicate and interact more effectively, and build more effective and efficient teams both internally and externally.

    1. Global Creative Leadership: One Leader Can Change Everything

    Archetype: Knowledgeable Sage
    The expert, scholar, detective, advisor, thinker, planner archetype. Think Yoda or the brand Dyson.


    This approach is largely characterized by a single leader, partnered closely with a C-suite level operator like a CMO. Global Creative Leadership elevates managing brand design from the top down and expands its role in the business, as the head of design creates the vision for all facets, from strategy to execution. This approach sets a bar for consistency across projects, brands teams and regions. It often vaults design, process (and budgets) while guarding brand equity. However, it can also represent the potential for stagnant design. When disconnected at the brand or project level, access from a single leader can be time-consuming. The question to ask yourself when considering this approach for your own company is: While vision is important at the top, how well will it trickle down?

    2. Design Management: One Design Manager per Brand Drives Efficiency

    Archetype: Helpful Caregiver
    Can be most closely compared to Mary Poppins or the brand Toms. A nurturing, helpful, best friend.


    Design managers become the go-between for agencies, internal clients or marketing teams. They are responsible for bringing to life the needs of the brand while delivering on the needs of the business. The benefits are quite simple: The design management approach represents a dedicated, expert resource for design and collaboration. While 10 years ago this role was very tactical, today it can be characterized by a stable and trusted brand stewardship, responsible for overseeing not only design but also brand identity and voice in several channels. This approach presents some challenges. Finding qualified design managers can be difficult, determining their ROI even more so. Establishing a consistent process and benchmarks while juggling different, often opposing agendas, desires and fears can also be a challenge. This matters because if the design management team isn’t critical to different agendas, the gaps in design leadership will be amplified and create risk. At every level your organization will need to get on the same page.

    3. Brand Management: With No Design Leadership, Life is Easier, Cheaper and Better

    Archetype: Confident Ruler
    Consider this archetype to be closer to a ruler or stable boss, confident leader or role model; like Warren Buffet or Microsoft.


    Where there is little to no management of brand design leadership internally, CPG agencies work directly with brands and marketing teams. The marketing organization is tasked with building the business, managing design and maintaining brand equities both with and without global creative leadership. This approach allows business needs to inform design directly. Teams share brand goals and collaborate effectively as a team. On the agency side, the approach is great for combining the design marketing team with the external brand management team. The agency defines and owns the process, outcomes and benchmarks. On the other hand, high turnover or account rotation on the part of the brand team can leave gaps in leadership. Agencies with minimal design background are challenged with leading brand management teams and it can be difficult to get design to be viewed as higher importance within the organization at the C-suite level. When considering this approach, remember the brand team may be consistent in their design role, but success depends on strong leadership from the agency side to keep the collaboration together—this means time and money. 

    4. Agency of Record (AOR): For the Agency, Being in Control Doesn’t Always Mean Freedom

    Archetype: Innovative Creator
    Independent, inventive and creative, like Steve Jobs or the brand Lego.


    An AOR relationship typically consists of a brand choosing an agency they could trust to be the ongoing brand steward for all creative work—allowing the brand to seek out an agency that suited their taste, rather than hire creatives internally. Even with an AOR relationship, work can be project-based. But this approach has the potential for creative solutions to become “expected” and defining the relationship between brand and agency as a vendor rather than a partner is a “watch out” from a creativity standpoint. For the agency, it’s easier to predict workload and create a staffing plan that benefits from the strategic relationships formed with the senior management, marketing teams and potentially other outside agencies. When considering, ask yourself: Can I find a permanent partner that can adapt as quickly as my brand?

    Will the Grass Always Be Greener on the Other Side?

    Yes, and no. Ultimately, it depends on what you’re working with right now. Getting an entire design management department to try a new approach is an undertaking with a lot of risk, but a study of these approaches can help you identify the benefits and pitfalls of each. That way, you have an idea of what the future will look like and whether or not you wish to adapt. In the constantly evolving world of CPG brand design, knowledge is key.
    ABOUT THE AUTHORS

    Scott Lucas is a second-generation branding and design leader who began his professional career 20 years ago as an account executive in Philadelphia and New York before moving to Cincinnati. As Managing Director, Scott leads the Brandimage North America team to deliver exceptional and meaningful branding and design solutions. For Scott, effective package design leverages an optimum mix of shopper motivation and consumer connection. He has created and implemented global packaging strategies in the U.S., Europe and Asia, and has worked in every category, from consumer products to pharmaceuticals.

    Jennifer Bethke brings 20+ years of experience as a designer, design director, packaging manager, and group account director to the Brandimage team. As Group Account Director, Jennifer has managed dozens of national and international packaging and branding projects, overseeing the client relationship, ensuring communications between team members, and providing adequate resources to her accounts. Prior to joining Brandimage, she was a design director for Primo Angeli, Inc., in San Francisco, a packaging manager for Nestlé Beverage in San Francisco, and a designer for Frankel and Co. in Chicago.
    Related Searches
    • marketing
    • leadership
    • Packaging
    • innovative
    Suggested For You
    Baralan USA Baralan USA
    Products by O2, Inc. Products by O2, Inc.
    Fusion Packaging Fusion Packaging
    Baralan USA Baralan USA
    DISC DISC
    Elle Morris Named CEO at HMSDesign Elle Morris Named CEO at HMSDesign
    Freeze 24-7 Skin Blizzard Offers Intensive Hydration Freeze 24-7 Skin Blizzard Offers Intensive Hydration
    Precise Packaging Precise Packaging
    Perricone MD Perricone MD
    Kaufman Container Kaufman Container
    Virospack Introduces Texturized End Decoration Virospack Introduces Texturized End Decoration
    Nuxe Adopts Oval Tense Tube from Cosmogen Nuxe Adopts Oval Tense Tube from Cosmogen
    Arcade Beauty Invests in New Sampling Technology Arcade Beauty Invests in New Sampling Technology
    Lindal Group Appoints Global Operations Director Lindal Group Appoints Global Operations Director
    Perricone MD Names New Chief Supply Chain Officer Perricone MD Names New Chief Supply Chain Officer

    Related Expert's Opinion

    • Beauty’s Retail Landscape Integrates with Technology

      Beauty’s Retail Landscape Integrates with Technology

      Beauty is far from a solely brick and mortar business.
      Elle Morris, CEO, HMS Design 04.19.18

    • Sustainable Pkg/Practices
      Beauty and the Environment

      Beauty and the Environment

      Women, shea trees and climate change
      Funlayo Alabi, co-founder, Shea Radiance 04.05.18

    • Fragrances
      From White Diamonds to Buttered Popcorn

      From White Diamonds to Buttered Popcorn

      In fragrance naming, as in life, seasons change.
      Rachel Bernard 03.29.18


    • NPD Details Top Trends in Beauty

      NPD Details Top Trends in Beauty

      And what the sports industry (and others) can learn from its success.
      Larissa Jensen and Matt Powell, NPD 03.19.18

    • The Art and Science of Raising Capital for a Beauty Brand

      The Art and Science of Raising Capital for a Beauty Brand

      A few guidelines can help you navigate the fundraising.
      Ilya Seglin 03.15.18

    • Decorative Effects | Design Capabilities | Package Development
      Using Sensory Cues to Deliver on Three Universal Consumer Desires

      Using Sensory Cues to Deliver on Three Universal Consumer Desires

      Guiding shoppers to the ‘moment of truth’ when they become customers
      Marty Gage 03.08.18


    • Driving Consumer Action

      Driving Consumer Action

      

Using buyer behavior to better package personal care products
      Tom Spina 02.28.18

    • FDA Cosmetic Regulations Should Support Businesses of All Sizes

      FDA Cosmetic Regulations Should Support Businesses of All Sizes

      ICMAD will work to help ensure they provide cosmetic companies with the guidance and clarity needed for future innovation.
      Pam Busiek, President and CEO, Independent Cosmetic Manufacturers and Distributors 02.26.18

    • Global Brands Are Dead

      Global Brands Are Dead

      Long live ‘glocal’ brands.
      Nick Vaus, partner & creative director, DewGibbons + Partners 02.22.18


    • Cultural Resonance with Beauty Consumers

      Cultural Resonance with Beauty Consumers

      Beauty brands need to communicate with a diverse audience in a resonant way.
      Elle Morris , CEO, HMS Design 02.15.18

    • The End to Paper Face Charts

      The End to Paper Face Charts

      Makeup artists go digital
      Krista McAulay, Makeup Artist & Marketing Manager, Perfect365, Inc. 02.01.18

    • Bath/Body | Personal Care
      The End of “Oil Free” Beauty

      The End of “Oil Free” Beauty

      Embracing the Emerging Global Natural Oils
      Funlayo Alabi, Co-Founder, Shea Radiance 01.04.18

    • Africa: A New Beauty Frontier

      Africa: A New Beauty Frontier

      A window of opportunity opens for global brands
      Elle Morris, CEO, HMS Design 12.21.17

    • Omni-channel Is Disrupting the Beauty Purchase Journey

      Omni-channel Is Disrupting the Beauty Purchase Journey

      Five tips for gaining a competitive edge
      Alex Xiaoguang Zhu and Julia Lang 11.30.17

    • Skin Care/Sun Care
      How Beauty Trends Differ Throughout Asia

      How Beauty Trends Differ Throughout Asia

      Japanese, Chinese and Korean consumers seek different solutions.
      Elle Morris, CEO, HMS Design 10.26.17

    Breaking News
    • Coty Debuts First-of-its-Kind Beauty 'Magic Mirror' at Bourjois Boutique
    • Maybelline New York Has A New Global Spokesmodel
    • REN Skincare's Recyclable Bottle Contains Reclaimed Ocean Plastic
    • This New Cannabis-Inspired Fragrance is Celebrating 4-20 Today
    • MAC Partners with Puma -- So Sneakers Now Match Lipstick
    View Breaking News >
    CURRENT ISSUE

    March 2018

    • Digital Printing Delivers in Many Ways
    • Precision Dispensing
    • Color Cosmetics: Packaging Self-Expression
    • View More >

    Copyright © 2018 Rodman Media. All rights reserved. Use of this constitutes acceptance of our privacy policy The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Rodman Media.